Post
by Icearstorm » Tue Sep 27, 2016 7:48 am
It looks a bit big-headed for a sharpie... Cooper's look almost exactly the same, apart from their larger, blocky heads, curved tails, and generally larger size (though a small male Cooper's will be about the same size as a large female sharp-shin). I've never seen Sharp-shinned Hawks more than a few feet away from cover, but have seen Cooper's Hawks hanging out on lampposts and roofs. And then there's that extremely rare possibility that this is a juvenile goshawk. They usually have bold white lines above their eye ridges (superciliary stripes), are extremely secretive, and live exclusively in colder environments (with the exception of escaped falconry birds)... This one doesn't seem to fit any of those criteria.
The dark eye is really throwing me off... It could be a trick of the light, but if not, this is almost definitely a buzzard (though we also call them hawks in the US). Most raptors' eyes darken with age and change into an adult plumage on their second year, but the true hawks only keep their brown plumage for their first year before molting into plumage with a reddish underside and slate blue uperside. By the time that their eyes would turn dark, they would probably be at least two or three- and therefore in adult plumage. Buzzards, on the other hand, tend to stay brown, though red-tailed hawks gain a red tail on their second year.
Of course, seeing the overall structure is important. I can't exactly tell from the photo, but if you get a chance to see it again you may be able to identify it.
Long tail + mid-length wings= true hawk/ shortwing/Accipiter
Short tail + relatively long wings= buzzard/broadwing/Buteo