Do Finches Need Grit?

Learn what to feed your birds.
kenny66
1 Egg Laid
1 Egg Laid
Posts: 680
Joined: Sun Dec 18, 2011 4:50 am
Location: Far North Queensland Australia
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by kenny66 » Mon Feb 13, 2012 6:28 pm

christel7 wrote:@kenny 66.
Which brand of grit-charcoal-iodine mix do you feed?
Thx,
Christel
Hi Christell

I just ordered medium sized crushed charcoal from Birds R Us yesterday. I also order charcoal a grit mix from Tweeta online which has iodine in it. One thing I notice is that the birds swap between the iodine added grit to normal grit as needed. You can also buy thos charcoal iodine "bells" so cheap which hang on the side of the cage. I smash these up with a hammer which the birds love.
kenny66
Red,black and yellow headed gouldians-red and yellow painteds-RC cordon bleus-jacarinis-St Helenas-orange breasted WB-ruddies-pied red face parrot finches-red and yellow stars-canaries-4 indoor cats formerly rescue cats

User avatar
fabulousfinch
Mature
Mature
Posts: 147
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 1:25 am
Location: Murfreesboro, TN
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by fabulousfinch » Wed Feb 15, 2012 3:24 pm

Paradise Aviary wrote:That was a very interesting and detailed article !!! And the picture is beautiful, thank you Bill =D>
Thanks, Rancel :D

Bill

User avatar
RigorMortisKitten
Persistent Pursuer
Persistent Pursuer
Posts: 295
Joined: Sun Nov 06, 2011 1:18 pm
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by RigorMortisKitten » Mon Feb 20, 2012 7:08 pm

Thank you for an interesting and well written text :)

What im wondering though - is what "grit" really is! Here in sweden - they sell "bird sand" - its sand for the bottom of the cage, and also contains oystershell and charcoal.

Its just plain grey sand, like this, but with pieces of oystershell!
Image

My question is - what in it do the birds actually eat ? :shock: Do they eat the SAND or the oystershells ? Is it the sand that is refered to as grit, or the oystershell pieces ?
Image
Society finches: Osiris, Anubis, Stains and Hurricane Gilbert

kenny66
1 Egg Laid
1 Egg Laid
Posts: 680
Joined: Sun Dec 18, 2011 4:50 am
Location: Far North Queensland Australia
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by kenny66 » Mon Feb 20, 2012 7:59 pm

grit here comprises crushed oyster shell (as a calcium supplement) and in some cases charcoal. Sand has no medicinal proeprties but is used by the birds to grind their food. As birds have no teeth the sand and grit grinds the seed in the crop. So ideally you would either have sand and crushed oyster shell mixed together or just crushed oyster shell. The sand by itself provides no calcium but does allow the bird to mash up its food in its crop.
kenny66
Red,black and yellow headed gouldians-red and yellow painteds-RC cordon bleus-jacarinis-St Helenas-orange breasted WB-ruddies-pied red face parrot finches-red and yellow stars-canaries-4 indoor cats formerly rescue cats

User avatar
PrettyBird
Proven
Proven
Posts: 2143
Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2011 7:51 pm
Location: Alberta, Canada

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by PrettyBird » Tue Feb 21, 2012 10:59 am

finchandlovebird wrote:In separate treat cups, I provide Kaytee Hi-Cal Grit supplement & Snack Attack Mineral Grit Oyster Shell & Mineral Treat (green in color & smells like anise). All my birds (Goulds, Canaries, Waxbills) snack on this stuff all the time.
I give my birds the Kaytee Hi-Cal Grit as well. They all eat it, even the goulds and Java's
Dee
English & American Budgies, Gouldians
Image
AACC member
http://lilbirdtoys.weebly.com

User avatar
RigorMortisKitten
Persistent Pursuer
Persistent Pursuer
Posts: 295
Joined: Sun Nov 06, 2011 1:18 pm
Location: Stockholm, Sweden

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by RigorMortisKitten » Tue Feb 21, 2012 12:43 pm

thank you for explaining kenny :) i'll stick with the sand with oystershell then :D my birds really like to walk around on the bottom of the cage and pick out pieces of oystershell, so i think its great entertainment for them
Image
Society finches: Osiris, Anubis, Stains and Hurricane Gilbert

User avatar
finchmix22
Mod Extraordinaire
Mod Extraordinaire
Posts: 6258
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 3:25 pm
Location: DFW TX

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by finchmix22 » Tue Feb 21, 2012 1:06 pm

I gave grit in the beginning of raising finches, but then they started to ignore the grit. I may try offering it again and see what they do. Thanks for the info.
DEBORAH

Image

User avatar
dfcauley
Molting
Molting
Posts: 6892
Joined: Sun Mar 23, 2008 9:28 am
Location: Carrollton, Georgia

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by dfcauley » Tue Feb 21, 2012 1:39 pm

I had a discussion about this with Laraine at the bird mart this weekend. Of course there are many theories on weather they need grit or not.......
I offer the F-Vite mixed in with eggshell and a little charcoal. I have noticed that my birds will gorge on the charcoal if I let them. Laraine says it can take away the nutrients from the other veggies and things that we give our birds so I am offering less of it.
Donna

User avatar
fabulousfinch
Mature
Mature
Posts: 147
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 1:25 am
Location: Murfreesboro, TN
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by fabulousfinch » Tue Feb 21, 2012 8:24 pm

RigorMortisKitten wrote:Thank you for an interesting and well written text :)

What im wondering though - is what "grit" really is! Here in sweden - they sell "bird sand" - its sand for the bottom of the cage, and also contains oystershell and charcoal.

Its just plain grey sand, like this, but with pieces of oystershell!
[ http://djursport.com/media/catalog/product/cache/2/image/300x300/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/9/5/953140.jpg ]

My question is - what in it do the birds actually eat ? :shock: Do they eat the SAND or the oystershells ? Is it the sand that is refered to as grit, or the oystershell pieces ?
Thanks :)

Kenny's got you covered on your question...sounds like you've got a good product in your "bird sand." Also, Debbie posted some good information on the different forms of calcium (can't find it right now) so the one thing you could add to your cage in addition to the bird sand is other soluble grit forms like egg shell, ground cuttlebone, etc. Different forms of soluble grit provide different forms of calcium which are absorbed by the body at different rates, so a diversity of soluble grits is a benefit to your birds.

Bill

User avatar
fabulousfinch
Mature
Mature
Posts: 147
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 1:25 am
Location: Murfreesboro, TN
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by fabulousfinch » Tue Feb 21, 2012 8:41 pm

finchmix22 wrote:I gave grit in the beginning of raising finches, but then they started to ignore the grit.
Hi Deborah,

That sounds perfectly normal for healthy birds. They will slow down in particular when not breeding and pick at it as they need. They will only gorge on it if they have a diet imbalance or health problem (a good indicator for both). They will also hit it hard when laying and feeding nestlings.

Bill

User avatar
finchmix22
Mod Extraordinaire
Mod Extraordinaire
Posts: 6258
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2010 3:25 pm
Location: DFW TX

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by finchmix22 » Tue Feb 21, 2012 8:50 pm

If I'm supplying them with cuttlebone and crushed hardboiled eggs, does that cover the grit issue? Should I be adding the charcoal/sand or something else?
DEBORAH

Image

User avatar
fabulousfinch
Mature
Mature
Posts: 147
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 1:25 am
Location: Murfreesboro, TN
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by fabulousfinch » Tue Feb 21, 2012 9:35 pm

finchmix22 wrote:If I'm supplying them with cuttlebone and crushed hardboiled eggs, does that cover the grit issue? Should I be adding the charcoal/sand or something else?
Hi Deborah,

That's a good start, and may well be sufficient. I can't find Deb's post, but it talks about the different forms of calcium, so the more diversity the better. I would certainly add some charcoal and sand (about 5% each should do it) and also oyster shell to what you're already using (don't quit on the cuttlebone and crushed eggshell).

I use ABBA Mineral Grit which includes: Sterilized Oyster Shell, Mollusk Shell, Sterilized Egg Shell, Sea Sand, Charcoal, Refined Bone Meal, etc. Not a sales pitch, you can buy it many places. But it is a well formulated grit due to its diversity. The poultry industry uses oyster and mollusk shell due to the different release rates of calcium. The body absorbs one form quickly, the other more slowly (can't remember which is which).

I'm sure your doing fine with cuttlebone and eggshell, but more diversity is even better :D

Bill

kenny66
1 Egg Laid
1 Egg Laid
Posts: 680
Joined: Sun Dec 18, 2011 4:50 am
Location: Far North Queensland Australia
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by kenny66 » Tue Feb 21, 2012 10:34 pm

finchmix22 wrote:If I'm supplying them with cuttlebone and crushed hardboiled eggs, does that cover the grit issue? Should I be adding the charcoal/sand or something else?
I will try and sum up the grit issue from my point of view. I hope it is helpful.

1. Cuttle bone and hardboiled eggs are not grit. They are a natural calcium supplement, and calcium, as most people will know is essential, in some form, for all birds.
2. Grit is a medium that birds use to grind up their food because the have no teeth. Once swallowed it enters the crop and acts like a grinding stone to prepare the seed for digestion. It also mixes the predigested food with benedficial bacteria already existing within the crop.
3. Grit does not always contain any calcium. Spinefex pigeons and a host of other species within Australia and the rest of the world swallow small stones and sand and pebbles and a host of other grinding material to break down their food. Ostriches, emus, cassowaries and most pigeon and dove species swallow small pebbles. They obtain calcium from other sources or exist, as some of the dessert species do, on very low levels of calcium. I use crushed oyster shells and normal sand for this purpose
Most of these dessert species are also efficient is storing and releasing calcium slowly into their system.
4. As you will know, calcium is necessary for egg production and bone development, particularly during the breeding season and, as birds cannot access it as they would in the wild from plants- minerals and wherever else, we need to provide it to them as a supplement. I dont provide water soluble calcium supplements, exept in cases of egg binding or an emergency (usually orally) because the concentrations taken in by the birds cannot be controlled. So my view that it is a hit and miss method. I provide crushed cuttle bone, egg shells (microwaved for 2 minutes) and crushed oyster shells (which also acts as a grit) for calcium supplementation.
5. Charcoal is a naturally occuring product accessed by finches in the wild for both medicinal and nesting purposes. My finches take it regularly and, apart from the carbon "mineral tonic" and impurities removal properites it has fort them, both the waxbills and Australian species use it as a significant component of their nest buildings. The painteds , for example layer it during the construction of the nest and continually replace it during the raising of chicks as a nest deoderiser. All of my waxbills use it in various quantities as do the red faced parrot finches. Ther is a view amongst some finch breeders that over supplementaion and over medication does more harm than good. Therefore I and most of the breeders I know try and keep it natural with products such as charcoal-crushed cuttlebone, oyster shells and naturally produced grit products and minimise supplementation. However we all use some supplementation, hoping our feathered friends actually consume it (and sometimes they dont!!!)
6. Finch breeding and husbandry is not an exact science and there are many differnt opinions on how to successfully look after birds. This is how I do it and have had very few problems. However other methods have the same or better success as well.
7. The supplements I use on a regular basis are iodine (mixed with charcoal) as finch diets are usually deficient in it-a water based nutrient supplement (such as nutriboost) during the breeding season 2 days per week-apple sider vinegar (as a water sanitiser and to lift the acid levels within the crop which is important for Australian finches). I also use this and a probiotic replacer such as ProBac after the worming and coccidiosis regime which I religiously do every 3 months. Of course I provide egg food-insectivor powder, biocal mineral granules and PVM powder ad lib. These I believe provide a reservoir of supplementation just in case. Apart from the egg food they are probably not essential and the birds seem to consume very little of them.. One observation is that I have never been into a finch aviary located near where I live that did not have grit and charcoal available to the birds. I also have never had a case of my birds over indulging on either grit or charcoal.
kenny66
Red,black and yellow headed gouldians-red and yellow painteds-RC cordon bleus-jacarinis-St Helenas-orange breasted WB-ruddies-pied red face parrot finches-red and yellow stars-canaries-4 indoor cats formerly rescue cats

User avatar
BillD
4 Eggs Laid
4 Eggs Laid
Posts: 827
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2008 9:30 pm
Location: Dallas/Fort Worth Texas

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by BillD » Tue Feb 21, 2012 11:16 pm

Thank you for posting all this information. I recently lost an Owl because of my ignorance. Consensus was she was egg bound. I did have a cuttlebone in her flight and she vigorously munched on it.

I have a new hen. Have Crushed Oyster shells for her now, but I would like to know more about the charcoal. I have aquariums and wonder if the charcoal used in them is the same you offer yours.

Would appreciate your knowledge.
2 polydactyl Snowflake felines and a new Panther non-poly feline.. Working on building the bloodline of the local Fawn Owls.

kenny66
1 Egg Laid
1 Egg Laid
Posts: 680
Joined: Sun Dec 18, 2011 4:50 am
Location: Far North Queensland Australia
Contact:

Re: Do Finches Need Grit?

Post by kenny66 » Tue Feb 21, 2012 11:40 pm

i bred tropical fish, african cichlids, for years, so i had a lot of aquarium charcoal left over. From memory this is activated charcoal and I now use just normal crushe charcoal which i get from the local store which is very inexpensive
kenny66
Red,black and yellow headed gouldians-red and yellow painteds-RC cordon bleus-jacarinis-St Helenas-orange breasted WB-ruddies-pied red face parrot finches-red and yellow stars-canaries-4 indoor cats formerly rescue cats

Post Reply